She was always into Karma (Katie Stevens) and has finally managed to squash all of the feelings she had for her by spending the summer apart from her, but Amy (Rita Volk) could quickly learn that she's not that evolved after all and could still be having feelings for friends on Faking It.

Now, she will realize that maybe instead of Karma, she's starting to feel something for Sabrina (Sophia Taylor Ali), who, in her attempt to potentially steal Amy away from Karma and keep her for herself, told Amy she was also questioning her sexuality. Now, with that fresh in mind, Amy will find herself getting ready to reject Karma in her dreams-and willing to accept Sabrina instead.

"Seeing how close you and Sabrina were tonight at game night...it drove me a little crazy," Karma says in Amy's dream, in a preview clip for the Tuesday, May 3 episode. "And I think I finally realize why."

Karma then leans in and engages in a full-on make out session with Amy-but she quickly puts a stop to things and pushes Karma away.

"No, I cannot go back there with you," Amy says in the clip.

Karma then appears ready to walk out, dejected, when Amy reaches out for her hand again, but when she turns around, Karma is no longer standing there. Sabrina however, is.

"Maybe you can go there with me," Sabrina seductively says, before she and Amy lean in.

Now, Amy will potentially be setting herself up for another fall, though she doesn't realize how epic it could be. Sabrina told her she was questioning her sexuality, knowing it would give her an in with Amy that Karma doesn't have following their complicated history. And Karma could be the one to discover that Sabrina is lying, and will have to let Amy know do she doesn't get her feelings hurt again. In the meantime however, Amy will continue believing Sabrina is the perfect new girlfriend for her.

Faking It airs Tuesdays at 10:30 p.m. on MTV.