Since Justin Bieber and Selena Gomez started dating in 2011, a never ending spew of reports come out daily debating whether the couple is still together or have broken up. 

Their relationship status may be the topic of discussion for many Beliebers and Selenators, but Enstars chooses to focus rather on the better times - when the singers were together and blissfully happy. Photos of Gomez and Bieber together are not hard to find - with them providing some of the pictures themselves online - and here are some of the best ones. 

At the height of their relationship, they made a number of public appearances together.

They attended the 2011 MTV Video Music Awards in Los Angeles together in August. Gomez wore a black dress that had sheer panels on the side and was short in the front but long in the back. For photographers, they embraced each other and Bieber sported red pants, leopard printed sneakers, and a black blazer over a loosely fitted black shirt. They also hugged after Bieber won the Best Male Video award for U Smile. 

Two months before, Bieber accepted the International Video of the Year by a Canadian award for Somebody to Love by Gomez, the night's host at the MuchMusic Video Awards in Toronto, June 19, 2011.   

Not shying away from the cameras, they posed on the red carpet together at the 2011 American Music Awards. For the November event, held in Los Angeles, Gomez wore a long, flowy copper toned dress and Bieber looked dashing in a black suit that he matched with a black bowtie while his hair was slicked to the side. Bieber kisses Gomez on the cheek for the cameras and even carried the train of her dress as they made their way inside the venue. 

Once 2012 started, the couple began to face rumors of a breakup and leading into 2013, they were said to be completely done with the relationship. Still, rumors of a "reconciliation" or of them "getting back together" did not stop. In April 2013, Bieber uploaded onto Instagram a photo of him sitting topless in a chair as Gomez hugs him from behind. He captioned the shot, " 'You've been making music for too long babe come cuddle' - her."  

In early of this year, he posted another Instagram photo of him and his ex-girlfriend. The respective picture shows them sitting close together as Bieber takes the picture himself. He captioned the photo, #heartbreaker," a nod to his single debuting soon with the same name.  

Which photos do you like of them together?