Mar 05, 2014 04:44 PM EST By Lauren DuBois

‘Amish Mafia’ Fake? New Claims About Cast Dispute Validity of Hit Cable Reality Series [PHOTOS]

As Discovery's Amish Mafia continues with its third season, new claims have surfaced which may prove the show is entirely fictional.

PREV
1 of 10
NEXT
  • Amish Mafia Cast members
  • Exclusive photo obtained by EnStarz.com featuring "Amish Mafia" star Merlin shopping in Ohio.
  • Esther Schmucker from 'Amish Mafia' Outside of Her Traditional Amish Clothing. She captioned this February 2014 photo "Out and about with some friends. Let's see what kind of trouble we can find tonight. #notbaptized #rumschpringa #weekendlife #friends."
  • Esther Schmucker from 'Amish Mafia' Outside of Her Traditional Amish Clothing
  • Photo collage of 'Amish Mafia' star Alan Beiler with girlfriend Ashley Rae, who he is expecting a child with
  • 'Amish Mafia' Star Alan Beiler
  • 'Amish Mafia' Star Jolin Zimmerman in a September 2013 photo
  • 'Amish Mafia' Star Jolin Zimmerman in a Feb. 2014 photo snowmobiling with his fiancee's family in the Adirondacks
  • Alvin from "Amish Mafia" in an undated photo
  • 'Amish Mafia' Star John Schmucker in a Feb. 2014 photo
  • Photo Credit Discovery Channel/Jason Elias
  • Photo Credit EnStarz
  • Photo Credit Facebook/Esther Schmucker
  • Photo Credit Facebook/Esther Schmucker
  • Photo Credit facebook/Alan Beiler "The Black Amish Man"
  • Photo Credit facebook/Alan Beiler "The Black Amish Man"
  • Photo Credit facebook/Jolin Zimmerman-Amish Mafia
  • Photo Credit facebook/Jolin immerman-Amish Mafia
  • Photo Credit facebook/Amish Alvin
  • Photo Credit facebook/John Schmucker

LOAD MORE