November 26, 2014 | Updated at 03:08 PM EST The Latest Entertainment & Celebrity News

‘Amish Mafia’ Fake? New Claims About Cast Dispute Validity of Hit Cable Reality Series [PHOTOS]

Amish Mafia
Amish Mafia - Merlin
Esther Schmucker from 'Amish Mafia' Outside of Her Traditional Amish Clothing
Esther Schmucker from 'Amish Mafia' Outside of Her Traditional Amish Clothing
Photo collage of 'Amish Mafia' star Alan Beiler with girlfriend Ashley Rae, who he is expecting a child with
'Amish Mafia' Star Alan Beiler
'Amish Mafia' Star Jolin Zimmerman in a September 2013 photo
'Amish Mafia' Star Jolin Zimmerman in a Feb. 2014 photo snowmobiling with his fiancee's family in the Adirondacks
Alvin from "Amish Mafia" in an undated photo
'Amish Mafia' Star John Schmucker in a Feb. 2014 photo
  • Amish Mafia
  • Amish Mafia - Merlin
  • Esther Schmucker from 'Amish Mafia' Outside of Her Traditional Amish Clothing
  • Esther Schmucker from 'Amish Mafia' Outside of Her Traditional Amish Clothing
  • Photo collage of 'Amish Mafia' star Alan Beiler with girlfriend Ashley Rae, who he is expecting a child with
  • 'Amish Mafia' Star Alan Beiler
  • 'Amish Mafia' Star Jolin Zimmerman in a September 2013 photo
  • 'Amish Mafia' Star Jolin Zimmerman in a Feb. 2014 photo snowmobiling with his fiancee's family in the Adirondacks
  • Alvin from "Amish Mafia" in an undated photo
  • 'Amish Mafia' Star John Schmucker in a Feb. 2014 photo
  • See More...

1 / 10

Is 'Amish Mafia' Fake? A New Report Claims the Cast Members are all Paid Actors Who don't live Amish lifestyles

CREDIT: Discovery Channel/Jason Elias 10:10

Read Article

Real Time Analytics