The Top 4 Idol-ers will tackle the theme "Break-Ups/Make-Ups". Jena Irene, Jessica Meuse, Alex Preston and Caleb Johnson take center stage for covers of the most theartbreaking and romantic songs.

Is American Idol Still Relevant? Falling Ratings

These are the songs that made the cut, as reported by TVLine on May 7.

For Jessica Meuse

Lady Gaga's You and I
Kelly Clarkson's Since U Been Gone

For Jena Irene:

Elvis Presley's Can't Help Falling in Love
Pat Benatar's Heartbreaker

For Caleb Johnson:

Paul McCartney's Maybe I'm Amazed
Bon Jovi's You Give Love A Bad Name

For Alex Preston:

Coldplay's Yellow
Alex Clare's Too Close

TVLine thinks that Johnson's song choice might be "disastrous" since Blake Lewis' performance of You Give Love A Bad Name is one of the greatest Idol moments of all time. Also Meuse covering Kelly Clarkson, the original Idol winner, well that just seems like a trap waiting to happen.

Check Idol's Biggest Competitor The Voice - Their Top 5 Singers

Preston's Yellow is right in his "wheelhouse" and Irene also has wise picks with Can't Help Falling In Love. This gives her a "shot at a true moment-moment."

Tune in tonight on Fox 8/7c for the sing-off as the Top 4 face off.

Top 4 American Idol Diary - Jessica Meuse


Top 4 American Idol Diary - Alex Preston


Top 4 American Idol Diary - Jena Irene


Top 4 American Idol Diary - Caleb Johnson

Tags: American Idol fox television