May 27, 2015 | Updated at 11:12 AM EDT The Latest Entertainment & Celebrity News

Critics Pan 'Charmless' Spice Girls Musical

They came, they saw, but sadly Britain's music critics largely failed to enjoy Tuesday night's revival of girl power at the world premiere of the Spice Girls' musical "Viva Forever!"

By Paul Casciato, Reuters on Dec 13, 2012 10:10 AM EST
facebook tweet this pin it plus
Sign Up for Newsletter
  • Spice Girl members Melanie Brown (R-L), Geri Halliwell, Emma Bunton and Melanie Chisholm arrive for the premiere of the musical "Viva Forever!", based on the music of the Spice Girls, in central Londo
  • Spice Girl members Melanie Brown (R-L), Geri Halliwell, Emma Bunton and Melanie Chisholm arrive for the premiere of the musical "Viva Forever!", based on the music of the Spice Girls, in central London December 11, 2012. (Photo : Reuters)

LONDON (Reuters) - They came, they saw, but sadly Britain's music critics largely failed to enjoy Tuesday night's revival of girl power at the world premiere of the Spice Girls' musical "Viva Forever!"

Reviewers panned a production loosely based on the band's meteoric rise to fame in the 1990s, complaining that its "charmless" script failed even as a basic invention for folding nostalgic pop hits into a West End stage show.


Independent newspaper critic Paul Taylor said the show "only achieves the kind of deliriously silly and joyous lift-off" at its encore and blamed scriptwriter Jennifer Saunders.

"Not only does her script rarely give you that necessary gleeful sense of expectancy about where the songs are going to be shoe-horned in, but it's embarrassingly derivative of 'Mamma Mia!' and looks way past its sell-by date in its utterly surprise-free satiric swipe at X Factor."

"Viva Forever!" was the brainchild of producer Judy Craymer, whose Mamma Mia! musical based on the hits of ABBA has earned nearly $2 billion worldwide and spawned a hit movie starring Meryl Streep.

She teamed up with British comedian Saunders of "Absolutely Fabulous" fame to create a story about the central character, Viva, a sprightly teenager who, along with her friends, gets into the final stages of a TV singing contest closely resembling Britain's "The X Factor".

To boost flagging audience figures - a nod to "The X Factor"s real-life ratings woes in Britain this season - their mentor springs a surprise and throws out three members of the band to leave Viva on her own.

What follows is part morality tale examining what is more important - friends, family or fame - and part satire on reality television, including a callous producer bearing an uncanny resemblance to X-Factor's Simon Cowell.

EMPOWERMENT

Both the Mirror and the Daily Mail delivered damning criticism of a production, which the Mirror's Alun Palmer said particularly failed to deliver on the grand message that formed a key part of every Spice Girl's identity: "girl power".

"There is more female empowerment at a Taliban finishing school than in this show," Palmer wrote.

The Spice Girls, Geri Halliwell, Victoria Beckham, Melanie Brown, Emma Bunton and Melanie Chisholm, who together stormed the charts in the 1990s and put girl power on the map were all on hand at the Piccadilly Theatre for the London premiere.

British tabloids made a good deal of noise out of the fact that Beckham arrived after her ex-bandmates and sat with her soccer star husband David and three sons, who clapped along to the music during the final medley.

Now all young mothers in their late 30s and early 40s, The Spice Girls are still affectionately known by their nicknames they adopted in the band - Posh (Beckham), Scary (Brown), Baby (Bunton), Sporty (Chisholm) and Ginger (Halliwell).

They were hailed as modern-day feminists by some and dismissed as vacuous pop princesses by others, but their success is beyond doubt. They sold 55 million records, had nine British No. 1 singles and three back-to-back Christmas No. 1s.

Unabashed fan Poppy Cosyns, was one of the few critics to gush enthusiastically about the show in her review for the Sun.

"As a true fan, I was worried that the jukebox musical formula might not work with their songs but Jennifer Saunders has done a great job with the script and the show flows really well," she wrote.

The band broke up around 12 years ago, their bickering eagerly chronicled by Britain's celebrity-obsessed tabloids.

Perhaps surprisingly, given the bust-ups and hissy fits, the group has been united in its backing of the new musical, and underlining the Spice Girls' lasting popularity, they played a major part in the closing ceremony at the London Olympics.

The Guardian's Alexis Petridis compared it favorably only to the "baleful shadow" of Ben Elton's Queen-themed "We Will Rock You" musical.

"It would be nice if, metaphorically speaking, it pinched Prince Charles's bum a few more times," he wrote. "Still, it zips along cheerily enough, and compared with We Will Rock You, it's a work of untrammeled genius."

Despite its flaws, Petridis said the show's success will lie in the hands of the legions of fans who propelled the Spice Girls to the top of the charts in the first place.

"Faint praise perhaps, but never mind: judging by the crowds of thirty-something ladies leaving the theatre singing 'Stop and Say You'll Be There', Viva Forever! is critic-proof." 

© 2015 Enstarz, All rights reserved. Do not reproduce without permission.

Tagged :   Spice Girls
facebook tweet this pin it plus
Contribute to this Story send us a tip send us a tip send us a tip
Sign Up for Newsletters

Around The Web

  • SEARCH ENSTARS

Aaron Hernandez & Tom Brady

Is Aaron Hernandez Using His 'Charm' To Get What He Wants Even From Behind Bars?

Bristol County Sheriff Thomas Hodgson discusses how Aaron Hernandez is a master manipulator.

Sawyer Fredericks

'The Voice' Season 8 Winner Returns To His Home On A Farm In Upstate New York

Sawyer Fredericks may have won Season 8 of 'The Voice,' but he has no intentions of trading his farm life for city living.

Anna and Josh Duggar

Who Were Josh Duggar's victims?

Which sisters were Josh Duggar's victims?

Rumer Willis

'DWTS' Champ Rumer Willis Reflects On Her Journey This Season

Rumer Willis reflects on her 'Dancing With the Stars' journey and why she's 'a bit sad' now.

Maddie Ziegler

Did Maddie Ziegler Make The Move To California?

Did Maddie Ziegler move to Hollywood along with Abby Lee Miller?

Sawyer Fredericks

'The Voice' Season 8 Winner Returns To His Home On A Farm In Upstate New York

Sawyer Fredericks may have won Season 8 of 'The Voice,' but he has no intentions of trading his farm life for city living.

Thomas Ravenel & Craig Conover

Did Thomas Ravenel Quit 'Southern Charm' After Filming Season 2?

Is Thomas Ravenel done with 'Southern Charm?'

Anna and Josh Duggar

Who Were Josh Duggar's victims?

Which sisters were Josh Duggar's victims?

Rumer Willis

'DWTS' Champ Rumer Willis Reflects On Her Journey This Season

Rumer Willis reflects on her 'Dancing With the Stars' journey and why she's 'a bit sad' now.

Kristen Stewart Robert Pattinson

Reporter Asks Kristen Stewart If She Is Still In Love With Robert Pattinson

It's been nearly three years since their break-up and the media is still wondering what the status is on Kristen Stewart and Robert Pattinson's relationship.

Jill Duggar

What Will TLC Do With Jill Duggar's Rumored Spin-Off Show?

Is TLC going to pull the plug on all of the Duggars?

Stevie J & Joseline Hernandez

'LHHATL' Husband & Wife Stevie J & Joseline Hernandez Go At It On Twitter

There's trouble in paradise with 'Love & HIp Hop Atlanta' stars Stevie J and Joseline Hernandez.

David Letterman

Where To Watch David Letterman's Final 'Late Show' Ever

Watch a free live stream of David Letterman's last 'Late Show' ever.

Jake starts becoming an issue for Sam's relationship with Patrick on the May 21, 2015 episode of 'General Hospital'

Jake & Sam Try To Uncover What Hayden Knows On 'General Hospital'

Hayden's claims about knowing who Jake really is are investigated.

Latest News

Andy Cohen & Bethenny Frankel

Bethenny Frankel Turns The Tables On Andy Cohen

Bethenny Frankel grills Andy Cohen on the Real Housewives franchise.

Maddie Ziegler

Maddie Ziegler's Career Is On Fire

Maddie Ziegler is the new face of Capezio.

Vicki Gunvalson

Vicki Gunvalson Opens Up About Going Under The Knife

Vicki Gunvalson wants to stay young looking forever.

George Clooney

George Clooney Is Not A Fan Of Plastic Surgery

George Clooney says he's never had a nip and tuck.

Jenelle Evans

Jenelle Evans Reportedly Assaulted Ex-Fiance Nathan Griffith, Warrant Issued

Jenelle Evans was reportedly involved in a dispute with Nathan Griffith on Tuesday night.

Jessica Lange

Jessica Lange Returns To Acting After Leaving 'American Horror Story'

Jessica Lange isn't giving up on acting just yet.

Nikolas and Elizabeth work to continue trying to keep their secret on the May 27, 2015 episode of 'General Hospital'

Elizabeth & Nikolas Worry That The Truth About Jake Could Still Be Revealed On 'General Hospital'

Elizabeth & Nikolas contine working to keep their secret despite suspicions.

Michael Clifford

Michael Clifford Dyes His Hair All Black While On Tour

5SOS member Michael Clifford loves hair dye and he recently switched up his hair color. Peep the picture here!

Evelyn Lozada

Evelyn Lozada's 'Giving Away' Her Wedding Dress From Her Short-Lived Marriage Chad Johnson

Evelyn Lozada appears to be looking for a fresh start as her OWN reality TV series premiere nears closer so she's giving away her wedding dress from when she got hitched to Chad Johnson.

Liam and Ivy's romance encounters another Steffy-sized problem on the May 27, 2015 episode of 'The Bold and the Beautiful'

Ivy & Liam's Romance Encounters More Problems When Steffy Returns On 'The Bold and the Beautiful'

Steffy's back and this time, she may not give up so easily on Liam

Featured Videos

From Our Partners

Call of Duty Advanced Warfare

'Call Of Duty: Advanced Warfare' Supremacy DLC Adds 4 Maps, Brings Bruce Campbell To Exo Zombies In June

Call of Duty: Advanced Warfare's next DLC, Supremacy, has been announced.

Candy Crush Saga

'Candy Crush Saga' Update Adds 15 New Levels Set In The Aquatic Delectable Depths

A new version of the popular mobile game is available on both the App Store for iOS and Google Play for Android, adding some new aquatic adventure to the game in the form of 15 new levels.

Dragon Age Inquisition

'Dragon Age: Inquisition' DLC 'Jaws Of Hakon' Launches On PS4, PS3 & Xbox 360 Today

EA ad Bioware have today released the Dragon Age: Inquisition Jaws of Hakon DLC for PlayStation 4, PlayStation 3 and Xbox 360.

Dying Light

'Dying Light' Free Update 1.06 Patch Notes: Parkour Challenges, Outfits, Be The Zombie Improvements & More

In addition to the new The Bozak Horde DLC releasing today, Dying Light also received a free content update.

Kholat

'Kholat' Launch Trailer Features Sean Bean Narrating Haunting, Mysterious Game

Developer IMGN.PRO has released a launch trailer for their upcoming title Kholat, which has the distinction of being narrated by the true king of Winterfell, Sean Bean.

The Witcher 3

'The Witcher 3' Free DLC Released, Missing Miners Mission & Alternate Yennefer Outfit Now Available

CD Projekt RED has released the next two Witcher 3: Wild Hunt DLCs announced earlier this week.

The Witcher 3

'The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt' Free DLC Will Add A New Mission & Alternative Look For Yennefer This Week

Two DLC releases are on the way this week, entirely free courtesy of developer CD Projekt.

Daniel Cormier

Daniel Cormier Next Fight: Ryan Bader 'Sick Of The Disrespect' DC Has Shown Him [VIDEO]

Ryan Bader did not take kindly to Daniel Cormier winning the UFC light heavyweight title and calling out Jon Jones

Sepp Blatter

FIFA Incarceration News: Sepp Blatter Not Arrested, 2018 and 2022 World Cup Go Ahead as Planned

Swiss authorities conducted an early-morning operation on Wednesday, arresting several top soccer officials and extraditing them to the United States on federal corruption charges. Backed by an F.B.I. investigation, the charges span more than 20 years and involve bids for World Cups, marketing and broadcast deals.

Gennady Golovkin

Gennady Golovkin Next Fight: Carl Froch Bout Pushed By Matchroom Sport Boss [VIDEO]

Gennady Golovkin vs. Carl Froch would definitely sell out 80,000-seat Wembley Stadium according to Matchroom Sport chairman Barry Hearn.

Real Time Analytics