April 27, 2015 | Updated at 11:30 AM EDT The Latest Entertainment & Celebrity News

Critics Pan 'Charmless' Spice Girls Musical

They came, they saw, but sadly Britain's music critics largely failed to enjoy Tuesday night's revival of girl power at the world premiere of the Spice Girls' musical "Viva Forever!"

By Paul Casciato, Reuters on Dec 13, 2012 10:10 AM EST
facebook tweet this pin it plus
Sign Up for Newsletter
  • Spice Girl members Melanie Brown (R-L), Geri Halliwell, Emma Bunton and Melanie Chisholm arrive for the premiere of the musical "Viva Forever!", based on the music of the Spice Girls, in central Londo
  • Spice Girl members Melanie Brown (R-L), Geri Halliwell, Emma Bunton and Melanie Chisholm arrive for the premiere of the musical "Viva Forever!", based on the music of the Spice Girls, in central London December 11, 2012. (Photo : Reuters)

LONDON (Reuters) - They came, they saw, but sadly Britain's music critics largely failed to enjoy Tuesday night's revival of girl power at the world premiere of the Spice Girls' musical "Viva Forever!"

Reviewers panned a production loosely based on the band's meteoric rise to fame in the 1990s, complaining that its "charmless" script failed even as a basic invention for folding nostalgic pop hits into a West End stage show.


Independent newspaper critic Paul Taylor said the show "only achieves the kind of deliriously silly and joyous lift-off" at its encore and blamed scriptwriter Jennifer Saunders.

"Not only does her script rarely give you that necessary gleeful sense of expectancy about where the songs are going to be shoe-horned in, but it's embarrassingly derivative of 'Mamma Mia!' and looks way past its sell-by date in its utterly surprise-free satiric swipe at X Factor."

"Viva Forever!" was the brainchild of producer Judy Craymer, whose Mamma Mia! musical based on the hits of ABBA has earned nearly $2 billion worldwide and spawned a hit movie starring Meryl Streep.

She teamed up with British comedian Saunders of "Absolutely Fabulous" fame to create a story about the central character, Viva, a sprightly teenager who, along with her friends, gets into the final stages of a TV singing contest closely resembling Britain's "The X Factor".

To boost flagging audience figures - a nod to "The X Factor"s real-life ratings woes in Britain this season - their mentor springs a surprise and throws out three members of the band to leave Viva on her own.

What follows is part morality tale examining what is more important - friends, family or fame - and part satire on reality television, including a callous producer bearing an uncanny resemblance to X-Factor's Simon Cowell.

EMPOWERMENT

Both the Mirror and the Daily Mail delivered damning criticism of a production, which the Mirror's Alun Palmer said particularly failed to deliver on the grand message that formed a key part of every Spice Girl's identity: "girl power".

"There is more female empowerment at a Taliban finishing school than in this show," Palmer wrote.

The Spice Girls, Geri Halliwell, Victoria Beckham, Melanie Brown, Emma Bunton and Melanie Chisholm, who together stormed the charts in the 1990s and put girl power on the map were all on hand at the Piccadilly Theatre for the London premiere.

British tabloids made a good deal of noise out of the fact that Beckham arrived after her ex-bandmates and sat with her soccer star husband David and three sons, who clapped along to the music during the final medley.

Now all young mothers in their late 30s and early 40s, The Spice Girls are still affectionately known by their nicknames they adopted in the band - Posh (Beckham), Scary (Brown), Baby (Bunton), Sporty (Chisholm) and Ginger (Halliwell).

They were hailed as modern-day feminists by some and dismissed as vacuous pop princesses by others, but their success is beyond doubt. They sold 55 million records, had nine British No. 1 singles and three back-to-back Christmas No. 1s.

Unabashed fan Poppy Cosyns, was one of the few critics to gush enthusiastically about the show in her review for the Sun.

"As a true fan, I was worried that the jukebox musical formula might not work with their songs but Jennifer Saunders has done a great job with the script and the show flows really well," she wrote.

The band broke up around 12 years ago, their bickering eagerly chronicled by Britain's celebrity-obsessed tabloids.

Perhaps surprisingly, given the bust-ups and hissy fits, the group has been united in its backing of the new musical, and underlining the Spice Girls' lasting popularity, they played a major part in the closing ceremony at the London Olympics.

The Guardian's Alexis Petridis compared it favorably only to the "baleful shadow" of Ben Elton's Queen-themed "We Will Rock You" musical.

"It would be nice if, metaphorically speaking, it pinched Prince Charles's bum a few more times," he wrote. "Still, it zips along cheerily enough, and compared with We Will Rock You, it's a work of untrammeled genius."

Despite its flaws, Petridis said the show's success will lie in the hands of the legions of fans who propelled the Spice Girls to the top of the charts in the first place.

"Faint praise perhaps, but never mind: judging by the crowds of thirty-something ladies leaving the theatre singing 'Stop and Say You'll Be There', Viva Forever! is critic-proof." 

© 2015 Enstarz, All rights reserved. Do not reproduce without permission.

Tagged :   Spice Girls
facebook tweet this pin it plus
Contribute to this Story send us a tip send us a tip send us a tip
Sign Up for Newsletters

Around The Web

  • SEARCH ENSTARS

Ray Romano

Ray Romano Is 'Terribly Saddened' Over Death Of Sawyer Sweeten

Comedian Ray Romano has expressed his grief over the tragic death of his former co-star Sawyer Sweeten.

Former NFL Patriots Football Player Aaron Hernandez

Aaron Hernandez Will Serve Life Sentence In Maximum Security Prison

Aaron Hernandez transferred to new prison.

Secrets and Lies on ABC

Will 'Secrets & Lies' Get A Second Season?

It has had some fairly good ratings during its limited run on ABC, and now, Secrets And Lies could become a contender for a season two pickup on the network.

Revenge

Major 'Revenge' Finale Death Revealed? Call Sheet Indicates Shocking Demise

One of Emily's love interests may kick the bucket.

Caroline might have a huge secret when she comes back to Forrester on 'The Bold and the Beautiful'

Will Caroline Return To L.A. With A Huge Secret On 'The Bold and the Beautiful?'

She's been off in New York for a while now, but when Caroline (Linsey Godfrey) returns to L.A. on The Bold and the Beautiful she could be revealing a big secret she was trying to keep hidden.

Jamie Dornan and Dakota Johnson

'Fifty Shades' Producers Looking To Cast New Actress For The Role Of Elena

Which A-list celebs will 'Fifty Shades' movie execs select to join the cast for the new sequel?

Secrets and Lies on ABC

Will 'Secrets & Lies' Get A Second Season?

It has had some fairly good ratings during its limited run on ABC, and now, Secrets And Lies could become a contender for a season two pickup on the network.

Lisa Rinna

Lisa Rinna Appeared In Playboy -- Twice

Lisa Rinna posed for Playboy not once, but twice.

The Cast of 'General Hospital' at the 39th Annual Daytime Emmy Awards

Get The Start Time, Nominees & Red Carpet Info Before The 2015 Daytime Emmy Awards Start

The 2015 Daytime Emmy Awards are tomorrow night, April 26th, and will broadcast live from Warner Bros. Studios in California.

Bruce Jenner

Stream Bruce Jenner's 20/20 Interview Live For Free

Live Stream Bruce Jenner's 20/20 interview with Diane Sawyer

Nicole tells Wyatt something unexpected on the April 24, 2015 episode of 'The Bold and the Beautiful'

Nicole Spills An Unexpected Secret To Wyatt On 'The Bold and the Beautiful'

The Spencers are hoping to learn the big secret that they know will help take Rick (Jacob Young) down, and they could possibly get the answers they didn't expect on The Bold and the Beautiful.

Trina Braxton

Details Behind 'Braxton Family Values' Star Trina Braxton's Ugly Split With Estranged Husband Gabe Solis

While fans tuned in to WeTV's Tamar & Vince featuring Tamar Braxton and Vincent Herbert, Braxton's sister Trina Braxton is going through an ugly divorce with her now estranged husband Gabe Solis.

Sister Wives

Robyn's Ex-Husband Refuses To Give Up Parental Rights & Meri Brown Leaves 'Sister Wives?'

The season 6 premiere of TLC's 'Sister Wives' is set for just a few weeks from now, and it appears that sources are saying Meri Brown will not be returning.

Kim Matula

Is Kim Matula Readying To Return To 'The Bld and the Beautiful' Full Time?

She left her very popular role on The Bold and the Beautiful at the end of last year to pursue other ventures, but new reports allege that Kim Matula wants to return to CBS and her role of Hope Logan once again.

Days of Our Lives

Is 'Days of Our Lives' About To Get Cancelled?

Though there are still several fans watching NBC's remaining soap opera Days of Our Lives, there are still signs that the 50-year-old program could be on its way to the chopping block.

Latest News

Survivor

Tyler Paranoid That Dan & Sierra Could Flip In New Episode of 'Survivor'

Watch the intense new promo for the next episode of 'Survivor: Worlds Apart.'

Norman Reedus on "The Walking Dead"

Norman Reedus Responds To Rumours He’s Leaving 'The Walking Dead'

The Cable Zombie Horror Show Fan Favorite Officially Confirms His Status As Part Of The Past, just As Season 6 Is About To Begin Shooting.

Kylie Jenner

Kylie Jenner Gets A Marriage Proposal From A Fan

Kylei Jenner receives a creepy marriage proposal from a fan.

Bethenny Frankel

Bethenny Frankel Is No Longer Homeless

Bethenny Frankel buys a new Soho pad.

Someone new figures out Maya's secret on the April 27, 2015 episode of 'The Bold and the Beautiful'

Someone New Learns The Truth About Maya On 'The Bold and the Beautiful'

It is quickly becoming common knowledge that Maya (Karla Mosley) has a huge secret on The Bold and the Beautiful, and as much as she wants to keep it contained and away from Rick (Jacob Young), the truth that she's transgender continues to threaten being revealed.

Fifth Harmony

5H Most Proud Of Fiercest Fans ARDY From 2015 Radio Disney Music Awards

Fifth Harmony loves their fans immensely and here's why...

At Kristen's lair, Brady and Melanie find themselves in a dangerous situation on the April 27, 2015 episode of 'Days of Our Lives'

Mel & Brady Wind Up In A Dangerous Situation On 'Days of Our Lives'

They came to Italy to confront her for stealing his baby with another woman, but now Kristen (Eileen Davidson) has put Brady (Eric Martsolf) and Melanie (Molly Burnett) into an extremely dangerous situation on Days of Our Lives.

Rookie Blue Season 5 Photos

Andy Attacked In New 'Rookie Blue' Sneak Peek, Nick Moves On With New Officer

Just when it looks like Sam is telling Andy about his baby on the way, she's attacked; as if right on cue, Nick might move on with another woman.

Ginnifer Goodwin

Snow Severely Injured In Promo For Next Episode of 'Once Upon a Time'

The next episode of 'Once Upon a Time' is going to have family reunions, plotting revenge and dragons.

Tori Spelling

Tori Spelling's Brother Spends Some Quality Time With Her Family

Tori Spelling and her children spend a little quality time with her brother Randy.

Featured Videos

From Our Partners

Halo 5 Guardians

'Halo 5: Guardians' Limited Edition Xbox One Console Confirmed, Not Yet Revealed

Special edition consoles for big games are always hot commodities, and it shouldn't be surprising that one is on the way for Halo 5: Guardians.

Silent Hills

'P.T.' Demo Getting Pulled From PS4 PSN Store As 'Silent Hills' Is Cancelled, Guillermo Del Toro Loses Another Project

Guillermo del Toro must be used to this by now. Another upcoming horror project has been laid to rest.

Pokemon Shuffle

'Pokemon Shuffle' Event Celebrates 3.5 Million Downloads With Mythic Pokemon, Celebi

Just two months after its release, Pokemon Shuffle has garnered a lot of downloads. To celebrate, a limited time event will feature Mythic Pokemon Celebi.

Warhammer 40,000: Regicide

'Warhammer 40000: Regicide' Gameplay Footage: This Isn't Your Granddad's Game Of Chess [VIDEO]

Hammerfall Publishing has released a behind the scenes look on their Early Access title, Warhammer 40,000: Regicide. Bobby Fischer, eat your heart out.

World of Tanks

'World Of Tanks' Grand Finals Results: Upsets, Bloodbaths And Eternal Glory From This Year's Championship Tournament

Over two days, 12 teams battled it out for the right to call themselves the best at World of Tanks. It was a hard road, and an unexpected one, but the winner is...

Bill Goldberg

Bill Goldberg Return WWE: Former Wrestling Star Addresses Possible Comeback, 'By Me And Me Only' [VIDEO]

'Sick and tired' of dealing with promoters, former WWE/WCW star addresses 'what's next'

Call of Duty Black Ops 3

Call Of Duty Black Ops 3 Details: Cooperative Campaign, Current Gen Console Exclusivity & More Confirmed

More details have been confirmed about Black Ops III following the title's gameplay debut.

Gennady Golovkin

Gennady Golovkin Next Fight: Miguel Cotto Asking GGG To 'Step Aside' And Allow Canelo Alvarez Bout This Fall [VIDEO]

Gennady Golovkin considering "step aside" deal to allow Cotto-Alvarez fight if winner guarantees to fight GGG next?

Shovel Knight

How To Find Kratos in ‘Shovel Knight’ For PS4, PS3, Vita & Unlock The Armor of Chaos [SCREENS, VIDEO]

Here's where to find exclusive boss Kratos in the PlayStation version of Shovel Knight. Defeating him earns you exclusive Armor of Chaos that you won't get on the other versions!

Katie Nolan

Katie Nolan On Floyd Mayweather: 'Garbage Time' Host Calls Money A 'Piece of Sh*t' Due To Domestic Violence History [VIDEO]

Katie Nolan pulled no punches while addressing Floyd Mayweather's domestic violence history

Real Time Analytics