August 31, 2015 | Updated at 09:07 PM EDT The Latest Entertainment & Celebrity News

'Amish Mafia' Fake? Merlin Miller Spotted in Ohio, Signing Autographs Before Season 2 Premiere [EXCLUSIVE PHOTO]

Amish Mafia debuted its second season on Tuesday night, with rumors and speculation swirling on social media about whether or not the show was fake. A new photo, obtained exclusively by EnStarz, might shed some light into the true reality of the Discovery Channel show. The photo shows star Merlin, the "boss of the Ohio mafia," seemingly out of character and taking photos with fans at an Ohio shopping mall.

EnStars on Aug 14, 2013 01:38 PM EDT
facebook tweet this pin it plus
Sign Up for Newsletter
Merlin Miller Amish Mafia Fake
Merlin Miller stars on the Discovery Channel show, "The Amish Mafia." (Photo : Discovery Channel)
Amish Mafia - Merlin
Exclusive photo obtained by EnStarz.com featuring "Amish Mafia" star Merlin shopping in Ohio. (Photo : EnStarz)

Amish Mafia debuted its second season on Tuesday night, with rumors and speculation swirling on social media about whether or not the show was fake.

A new photo, obtained exclusively by EnStarz, might shed some light into the true reality of the Discovery Channel show. The photo shows star Merlin Miller, the "boss of the Ohio mafia," seemingly out of character, in "non-Amish" clothing, taking a photo with fans at an Ohio shopping mall.

According to EnStarz' sources, Merlin was spotted shopping for shoes and clothes when a few fans of the hit show approached him and asked for a photo. He obliged -- and "even offered to autograph a photo headshot of himself," the source revealed about the encounter, which took place earlier this year.

Discovery's new series Amish Mafia follows the men who protect and maintain peace and order within the Amish community in Lancaster, PA and Holmes County in Ohio. The series follows "Lebanon Levi," along with three of his assistants, who are purported to protect the Amish community in Lancaster County. But a brutal feud brews when Ohio mafia boss Merlin tries to expand his territory in to Lebanon Levi's space.

Speculation about the show's reality has been a topic of conversation since the show first debuted last year. At the beginning of each episode, Amish Mafia starts off with a text panel that explains many of the events portrayed on the show are reenactments; this statement is repeated at the end of the episode in small print.

'Amish Mafia' Star Alan Beiler Gets Prison Time for Injuring State Trooper During Car Chase 

In the upcoming episode of Amish Mafia airing Aug. 20, Ohio Mafia Boss Merlin recruits Alan to go after Lebanon Levi. Freeman and John are causing trouble in town, which Esther worries will affect her community standing. Jolin rejoins Levi's crew after a promise is made.

Do you think the show is fake? Sound off in the comments, below.

Amish Mafia airs Tuesday night at 9 p.m. EST on The Discovery Channel. Watch a clip of Merlin on Amish Mafia:


© 2015 Enstarz, All rights reserved. Do not reproduce without permission.

Tagged :   Amish Mafia
facebook tweet this pin it plus
Contribute to this Story send us a tip send us a tip send us a tip
Sign Up for Newsletters

Around The Web

  • SEARCH ENSTARS

Kim Kardashian

Did Kim Kardashian Have The Worst Look Of The Night?

Kim Kardashian criticized for her maternity dress at the 2015 MTV Video Music Awards.

Jamie Dornan

New Report Urges Fans To Just Leave Jamie Dornan And Amelia Warner 'Alone'

Are Jamie Dornan and Amelia Warner really on the rocks?

Mimi Faust

'LHHATL' Shocker: Mimi Faust Throws In Towel On Joseline Hernandez Feud, How Does She Respond?

Mimi Faust is over her major beef with Joseline Hernandez, but is Hernandez just as willing to stop the feud?

Kaitlyn Bristowe

Is Kaitlyn Bristowe Set To Join 'Dancing With the Stars'?

Will Kaitlyn Bristowe be the latest 'Bachelor/Bachelorette' star to compete in 'DWTS'?

Draya Michele

'BBWLA' Stars Draya Michele & Brandi Maxiell's Beef Reaches New Heights On Instagram

Draya Michele and Brandi Maxiell are the latest ladies of 'Basketball Wives LA' to give fans a first row seat at their drama on social media, and it's pretty explosive.

Willie Nelson

Publication Claims Willie Nelson Has Passed At 81 During Death Hoax

When a publication falsely reported that Willie Nelson had died at age 81, the truth came out that it was incorrect.

Lil Scrappy

Lil Scrappy Reads Erica Dixon To Filth In Part 2 Of 'Love & Hip Hop Atlanta' Reunion

Lil Scrappy reaches his breaking point and lets it all out against Erica Dixon in a first look of the second part of the 'Love & Hip Hop Atlanta' reunion special.

Margaux

It Looks Like Margeaux's Plan To Fight Drama On The 'Love & Hop Hop Atlanta' Reunion Will Be An Epic Fail

Margeaux might have gotten more than she bargained for when she was tossed into Nikko Smith's drama during the reunion special of 'Love & Hip Hop Atlanta.'

Vicki Gunvalson

Vicki Gunvalson Denies Searching For A New Boyfriend, Says She's 'Missing' A Lot Of People

Vicki Gunvalson isn't moving on from Brooks Ayers quite yet.

Matt Bomer Simon Halls

Matt Bomer & Simon Halls To Be Honorees At Award Ceremony For Their Advocacy & Contributions

Matt Bomer and his husband, Simon Halls, are taking their activist skills to a special new level.

Brad Pitt

'Sons of Anarchy' Movie Hoax: Brad Pitt Is Not Playing John Teller In Feature Film

A 'Sons of Anarchy' movie hoax had many people fooled with claims that Brad Pitt would be playing a significant character.

Steve Burton & Sharon Case

Will Sharon Tell Dylan She Miscarried On 'Young and the Restless'?

There are always so many secrets that the Genoa City residents hold.

Leah Messer & Twins

Leah Messer's Alleged Boyfriend T.R. Dues Says Their Relationship Isn't Romantic

Leah Messer's alleged boyfriend claimed in a new interview that their relationship is not romantic.

Sawyer Fredericks

Sawyer Fredericks Teases Song 'A Good Storm' On Instagram!

Listen to a snippet of a song from Sawyer Fredericks that can wind up on his debut album here.

Sawyer Fredericks

Sawyer Fredericks Updates Fans On His Debut Album Status & Next Big Performance

Sawyer Fredericks' debut album is coming along swell and he will be performing at a pretty rad event next month.

Latest News

Wes Craven

Wes Craven's 'Scream' Co-Workers Express Their Grief Over His Death

After horror movie filmmaker Wes Craven died on Sunday, some actors who worked with him expressed their condolences.

The Librarians

Why Is Christian Kane Fighting Himself In The First 'Librarians' Promo?

Jake Stone will go up against a familar looking face in season 2

Marlee Matlin

'Switched At Birth' Actress Wants A Fifth Season

As 'Switched at Birth' gets back into the swing of things in the fourth season, one of the stars revealed that she wants a fifth season to happen.

Reign

It's A Battle Of The Queens In Latest Promo For 'Reign' Season 3

Expect a good haul of Queen Elizabeth in the third season of 'Reign.'

The Affair

'Nothing Hurts Like Love' In New Promo For 'The Affair' Season 2

The drama on 'The Affair' is going to get so much worse as everyone deals with their darkest emotions.

Britni Nicol

'Are You The One' Cast Member Says There Will Be 'Spice, Excitement & Drama' In The Third Season

One of the contestants of 'Are You The One' Season 3 is getting fans excited for upcoming episodes.

Hawaii Five-0

Special 'Hawaii Five-0' Halloween Treat For Danny & His Son

It's time for Danny to get to know Charles

The Originals

There Will Be A 'Whole Series Of Flashbacks' On 'The Originals'

Get ready for a blast to the past on 'The Originals.'

The Blacklist

Will Liz Give Into Her 'Criminal Instinct' On 'The Blacklist'?

Lizzie's time on the run will cause her to tap into her felonious urges.

Everybody Loves Raymond

Sawyer Sweeten Gets Mentioned In Original Review For 'Everybody Loves Raymond'

It's been four months since the tragic death of Sawyer Sweeten, but fans can take a look back on a certain mention of him from nearly 20 years ago.

Real Time Analytics