November 26, 2014 | Updated at 08:30 AM EST The Latest Entertainment & Celebrity News

‘Amish Mafia’ Fake or Real Claims & “Bigoted Attack” Allegation Published in Anabaptist Newspaper [VIDEO]

A January article in an Anabaptist newspaper has been circulating on social media lately for its claims that the Discovery Channel show Amish Mafia is nothing more than a bigoted attack on those of real Amish identity.

By Lauren DuBois, EnStars on Sep 24, 2013 02:00 PM EDT
facebook tweet this pin it plus
Sign Up for Newsletter
  • Amish Mafia
  • Amish Mafia Cast members (Photo : Discovery Channel/Jason Elias)

An article in an Anabaptist newspaper has been circulating on social media recently for its claims that the Discovery Channel show Amish Mafia is nothing more than a bigoted attack on Amish people. 

The article was written in January and first appeared in the Mennonite World Review, an independent newspaper that has served Mennonites and the global Anabaptist movement since 1923. Writer David George blasts the show for not only exploiting tragedies that have affected the Amish community, but for also embarrassing those who identify themselves as Amish.

"In an episode of the show in which they 'speak out' against claims of the show being fake-that there is no Amish mafia-the actors use as evidence the presence of their names in the genealogy book Descendants of Christian Fisher (the 'Fisher book' as it's commonly known to many Amish and Mennonites interested in their ancestry)," George wrote.

"If nothing else this scene makes clear that the show is a bigoted attack on Amish identity-one that has the audacity to use recent tragic episodes of Amish victimization while making its Amish participants look like buffoons."

George, a native of Lancaster County, referred to the recent Nickel Mines school massacre as well as attacks on Amish families by an Ohio cult, according to Lancaster Online.

The Ohio case involved a series of targetings in 2011 through Amish communities in eastern Ohio where a dissident sect broke into homes, restrained men and women, and forcibly cut their hair. The leader of the group was sentenced to 15 years in prison for his crimes earlier this year. The attacks were considered federal hate crimes because a woman's long hair and a man's long beard symbolize signs of submission to God to those who are Amish, according to the Los Angeles Times

'Amish Mafia' Season 3 Spoilers: Reality Show Making 'Special Episode' to 'Prove the Show is Real'? [VIDEO]

In 2006, a 32-year-old truck driver bent on revenge entered a one-room schoolhouse in Lancaster County, killing himself and four young Amish girls in the process.

Amish Mafia is not the only show focused on Amish culture that has made it onto television screens in recent year. TLC premiered Breaking Amish in 2012 and Breaking Amish: LA this year.

Watch a video about how the Amish community feels about Amish Mafia.

The returns for a special episode Tuesday at 9 p.m. on Discovery.


© 2014 Enstarz, All rights reserved. Do not reproduce without permission.

facebook tweet this pin it plus
Contribute to this Story send us a tip send us a tip send us a tip
Sign Up for Newsletters

Around The Web

  • SEARCH ENSTARS

Mimi Faust

Mimi Faust Reveals An Argument With Stevie J Landed Ex-Couple On 'LHHATL'

Fans have seen the evolution and end of Mimi Faust's relationship with her ex-boyfriend and the father of her child Stevie J on VH1's Love & Hip Hop Atlanta; now she has opened up about how the two landed a spot on the show begin with.

Timbaland

Timbaland On Wendy Williams Being Mean To Aaliyah When She Was Alive: 'I Was Naive Back Then'

Timbaland has opened up about rumors that Executive Producer Wendy Wiliams was rude to Aaliyah when it came to addressing her rumored marriage with R. Kelly.

Todd Chrisley

Todd Chrisley's First Wife Speaks On Gay Rumors, Confesses 'I Can See Why' There's Speculation

Just after 'Chrisley Knows Best' star Todd Chrisley's son, Kyle Chrisley claimed that he is homosexual, Todd's first wife has broken her silence on rumors.

Lil Fizz

'LHHH' Lil Fizz Blasts 'Thot' Amanda Secor, Possibly Moves On With Nikki Murdarris, 'She's Cool'

Amanda Secor & Lil Fizz's breakup is getting pretty ugly as he disses her big time and seems to move on with his Love & Hip Hop Hollywood co-star Nikki Murdarris.

Amanda, Fizz, Moniece

Are Fizz and Moniece Back Together? Rumors Fly as she Slaughters Amanda on Instagram & Calls Her Ex, "Mine"

Moniece Slaughter and Lil' Fizz's ex-girlfriend Amanda Secor still don't like each other and they are going at it on Instagram.

Witches Of East End

Chances Of A 'Witches Of East End' Renewal Are Reportedly Growing Stronger

The chances of 'Witches of East End' getting a renewal appear to be growing higher and higher.

Witches Of East End

'Witches Of East End' Actress Reveals Something She Heard That Should Encourage Fans To 'Keep Signing' The Petition

'Witches of East End' fans have done what they can to help bring the show back for new episodes, and it looks like all that work is gaining some positive attention.

WWE

WWE 'Raw' LIVE STREAM Free: Watch 'Monday Night Wrestling 2014' Online @ 8PM ET

Find out what's next for the WWE following Team Authority's defeat.

'The Voice' Season 7 Promotional Photo

A Glimpse Into The Top 10 Of Season 7 Of 'The Voice'

The Top 10 on Season 7 of 'The Voice' are set to perform Monday before eliminations take place Tuesday.

Masika Tucker

'LHHH' Masika Tucker Checks Yung Berg On Twitter 'Watch It', Rapper Confirms Return To Show? Says 'I'll Be Back'

It seems VH1's 'Love & Hip Hop Hollywood' Masika Tucker and Yung Berg are still going strong after he allegedly attacked her earlier this month.

WWE

WWE 'Survivor Series 2014' LIVE STREAM: Watch Team Authority vs Team Cena Online

Find out who will win when Team Authority and Team Cena go head to head.

Timbaland

Timbaland Reveals Alexandra Shipp Wrote Him Amid 'Aaliyah: Princess Of R&B' Backlash

Timbaland has spoken out in his first interview since slamming Lifetime's Aaliyah: Princess Of R&B and revealed lead actress Alexandra Shipp reached out to him during his rant.

Longmire

'Longmire' Star Robert Taylor 'Overjoyed' For 4th Season

'Longmire's' Robert Taylor, who has charmed fans for three seasons in the title role, is one of the show's few stars who lacks a strong social media presence

Jacqueline MacInnes Wood

Who Could Be The New Steffy Forrester On 'The Bold and the Beautiful?' Find Out Here!

There are set to be some major shake-ups coming on The Bold and the Beautiful-and they could come with the return of a very popular character!

Longmire

Lou Diamond Phillips Talks 'Longmire' Renewal

Actor Lou Diamond Phillips has invested much of his social media presence over the last few months in promoting 'Longmire' following A&E's cancellation of the popular crime drama.

Latest News

'Arrow'

Showrunner Dishes On Another 'Arrow/Flash' Crossover In Season 3

'The Flash's' executive producer, Greg Berlanti, dished about the possibility of another crossover with 'Arrow' in the current season of both shows.

Mahershala Ali

Remmy Lands A Really Great Job In Season 3 Of 'House of Cards'

Mahershala Ali, who plays Remmy, in 'House of Cards,' dished about his role in season 3 of the Netflix political drama.

Sammy Hagar

Sammy Hagar Guest Appears On 'The Simpsons' And Loves It

Sammy Hagar joined a long list of fellow rock stars last Sunday when he appeared on an episode of The Simpsons.

Danny and Mindy On the 'Crimes & Misdemeanors & Ex-BFs' Episode Of 'The Mindy Project'

Danny Becomes Involved In His Mom's Love Life When He Sets Her Up On A Blind Date On 'The Mindy Project'

In a season 3 episode 9 'How To Lose A Mom In Ten Days' spoiler video, actor Ike Barinholtz who plays Morgan Tookers on 'The Mindy Project' says this is his favorite episode yet.

Katherine Heigl

Katherine Heigl Is Learning More Than Just What POTUS Means As An Executive Producer On 'State Of Affairs'

'State of Affairs' is off to a great start as an NBC TV series, and when Katherine Heigl set out as an actress and executive producer for the show, she had her own goals.

Dancing With the Stars

'Dancing With the Stars' Results: Who Won The Seaso 19 Finals?

Find out who took home the Mirror Ball trophy.

White Collar

'White Collar' Series Finale To End With Cliffhanger; What Does This Mean For Fans?

Matt Bomer and Jeff Eastin discuss the 'White Collar' series finale.

The Mentalist

Romance Coming For Cho On 'The Mentalist'? Agent Vega Sparks A Love Triangle

What's going on between Agent Cho and Agent Vega?

Featured Videos

From Our Partners

realityrewind.com

'Dancing With the Stars' Season 19 Winner SPOILERS Sadie Robertson, Alfonso Ribeiro or Janel Parrish? Find Out Here

'Dancing With the Stars' Season 19 Winner SPOILERS Sadie Robertson, Alfonso Ribeiro or Janel Parrish? Find Out Here

The Voice - NBC

'The Voice' NBC Season 7 Top 8 Elimination Spoilers, Who Went Home Between Anita Antoinette, Ryan Sill and Reagan James?

'The Voice' NBC Season 7 Top 8 Elimination Spoilers, Who Went Home Between Anita Antoinette, Ryan Sill and Reagan James?

Fifth Harmony

Fifth Harmony 'Sledgehammer' New Music Video Released, Watch Here (VIDEO)

Watch Fifth Harmony's latest music video for their hit single 'Sledgehammer' here. (VIDEO)

Rex Ryan

New York Jets News And Rumors: Rex Ryan Knew Of John Idzik Plot To Fire Him? [VIDEO]

Rex Ryan himself knows his days are numbered -- in fact he apparently has known all along.

Nyko Intercooler

Nyko Black Friday Sales Offers Huge Discount On Every Peripheral Device And Free Shipping All Weekend

Peripheral controller and device company Nyko is selling every piece of hardware they make with a great discount this weekend. They're even offering to ship it all to you for free. Find out how inside.

Robert Griffin III

RG3 Trade Rumors: Philadelphia Eagles A Potential Landing Spot? [VIDEO]

Amid the multiple media reports that Colt McCoy shockingly - or not so shockingly - has beaten out Robert Griffin III for the starting quarterback job this week for the Washington Redskins, comes a forecast about Griffin's next assignment.

Warhammer 40,000: Armageddon

Warhammer 40,000 Armageddon Released On Steam Today; Purchase This Week For 25% Discount On TurnBased Title [VIDEO]

Slitherine has launched their hex-tile, turn-based strategy title Warhammer 40,000: Armageddon onto Steam today alongside a new launch trailer. The game pits you in a desperate, epic campaign against an Orkish invasion fleet.

Warhammer 40,000: Carnage

Warhammer 40,000 Carnage Infographics Shows That Players Have Administered Mayhem Aplenty On Mobile Devices

Developer Roadhouse Interactive has released a new infographic outlining the sheer amount of mayhem and brutality players have doled out in Warhammer 40,000: Carnage.

Robert Griffin III

Washington Redskins News and Rumors: RG3 Is BENCHED For Sunday, But Remains In Team's Future Plans? [VIDEO]

It looks like the end for the RG3 era in Washington. At least for this year.

Real Time Analytics