February 10, 2016 | Updated at 04:58 PM EST The Latest Entertainment & Celebrity News

‘Amish Mafia’ Fake or Real Claims & “Bigoted Attack” Allegation Published in Anabaptist Newspaper [VIDEO]

A January article in an Anabaptist newspaper has been circulating on social media lately for its claims that the Discovery Channel show Amish Mafia is nothing more than a bigoted attack on those of real Amish identity.

By Lauren DuBois, EnStars on Sep 24, 2013 02:00 PM EDT
facebook tweet this pin it plus
Sign Up for Newsletter
Amish Mafia
Amish Mafia Cast members (Photo : Discovery Channel/Jason Elias)

An article in an Anabaptist newspaper has been circulating on social media recently for its claims that the Discovery Channel show Amish Mafia is nothing more than a bigoted attack on Amish people. 

The article was written in January and first appeared in the Mennonite World Review, an independent newspaper that has served Mennonites and the global Anabaptist movement since 1923. Writer David George blasts the show for not only exploiting tragedies that have affected the Amish community, but for also embarrassing those who identify themselves as Amish.

"In an episode of the show in which they 'speak out' against claims of the show being fake-that there is no Amish mafia-the actors use as evidence the presence of their names in the genealogy book Descendants of Christian Fisher (the 'Fisher book' as it's commonly known to many Amish and Mennonites interested in their ancestry)," George wrote.

"If nothing else this scene makes clear that the show is a bigoted attack on Amish identity-one that has the audacity to use recent tragic episodes of Amish victimization while making its Amish participants look like buffoons."

George, a native of Lancaster County, referred to the recent Nickel Mines school massacre as well as attacks on Amish families by an Ohio cult, according to Lancaster Online.

The Ohio case involved a series of targetings in 2011 through Amish communities in eastern Ohio where a dissident sect broke into homes, restrained men and women, and forcibly cut their hair. The leader of the group was sentenced to 15 years in prison for his crimes earlier this year. The attacks were considered federal hate crimes because a woman's long hair and a man's long beard symbolize signs of submission to God to those who are Amish, according to the Los Angeles Times

'Amish Mafia' Season 3 Spoilers: Reality Show Making 'Special Episode' to 'Prove the Show is Real'? [VIDEO]

In 2006, a 32-year-old truck driver bent on revenge entered a one-room schoolhouse in Lancaster County, killing himself and four young Amish girls in the process.

Amish Mafia is not the only show focused on Amish culture that has made it onto television screens in recent year. TLC premiered Breaking Amish in 2012 and Breaking Amish: LA this year.

Watch a video about how the Amish community feels about Amish Mafia.

The returns for a special episode Tuesday at 9 p.m. on Discovery.


© 2016 Enstarz, All rights reserved. Do not reproduce without permission.

  • SEARCH ENSTARS

Latest News

The Fosters

Gabriel Does Not React Well To Jesus's Personal Questions On 'The Fosters'

It's going to be a struggle for Jesus to get to know his birth father on 'The Fosters.'

Chelsea Houska & Cole DeBoer

'Teen Mom 2' Chelsea Houska & Cole DeBoer Prepare Their Home For Marital Bliss

Chelsea Houska's latest Instagram photo shows she's truly ready to live as a wife to Cole DeBoer.

Lana Del Rey

Watch Lana Del Rey's New 10-Minute Music Video

The new music video also stars Father John Misty!

Vicki Gunvalson

Vicki Gunvalson Reunited With Two Former 'RHOC' Stars: Are They Returning For Season 11?

Could fans be seeing the return of two former 'RHOC' stars later this year?

Dan Bilzerian

Dan Bilzerian Brings 'New Talent To The Office'

Dan Bilzerian has some new accessories to add in his collection of not-so-typical stuff.

Agent Carter

Is Agent Carter's Cancellation At Hand? ABC Speaks Out As Atwell Lands New Role

Can Atwell pull of two series at the same time? Find out now.

Bernie Sanders

Here's How To Watch Bernie Sanders' Appearance On Colbert Tonight Without Cable Subscription

'Feel the Bern' tonight on the 'The Late Show' by watching his special appearance.

Erika Jayne

Erika Jayne Lies On 'RHOBH,' Then Proclaims She's Not A Liar In Her Blog

Erika Jayne is facing serious backlash on Twitter after blatantly lying to her co-stars on last night's 'RHOBH.'

American Horror Story

Should Mare Winningham Return For Another Supporting Role In 'American Horror Story'?

The character actress has played some brief yet memorable parts in 'AHS' over the years.

Gisele Bundchen Tom Brady

Report: Gisele Bundchen & Tom Brady's Marriage In Trouble

Are Tom Brady and Gisele Bundchen facing harsh times in their marriage?

Real Time Analytics