April 18, 2015 | Updated at 12:24 AM EDT The Latest Entertainment & Celebrity News

‘Amish Mafia’ Fake or Real Claims & “Bigoted Attack” Allegation Published in Anabaptist Newspaper [VIDEO]

A January article in an Anabaptist newspaper has been circulating on social media lately for its claims that the Discovery Channel show Amish Mafia is nothing more than a bigoted attack on those of real Amish identity.

By Lauren DuBois, EnStars on Sep 24, 2013 02:00 PM EDT
facebook tweet this pin it plus
Sign Up for Newsletter
  • Amish Mafia
  • Amish Mafia Cast members (Photo : Discovery Channel/Jason Elias)

An article in an Anabaptist newspaper has been circulating on social media recently for its claims that the Discovery Channel show Amish Mafia is nothing more than a bigoted attack on Amish people. 

The article was written in January and first appeared in the Mennonite World Review, an independent newspaper that has served Mennonites and the global Anabaptist movement since 1923. Writer David George blasts the show for not only exploiting tragedies that have affected the Amish community, but for also embarrassing those who identify themselves as Amish.

"In an episode of the show in which they 'speak out' against claims of the show being fake-that there is no Amish mafia-the actors use as evidence the presence of their names in the genealogy book Descendants of Christian Fisher (the 'Fisher book' as it's commonly known to many Amish and Mennonites interested in their ancestry)," George wrote.

"If nothing else this scene makes clear that the show is a bigoted attack on Amish identity-one that has the audacity to use recent tragic episodes of Amish victimization while making its Amish participants look like buffoons."

George, a native of Lancaster County, referred to the recent Nickel Mines school massacre as well as attacks on Amish families by an Ohio cult, according to Lancaster Online.

The Ohio case involved a series of targetings in 2011 through Amish communities in eastern Ohio where a dissident sect broke into homes, restrained men and women, and forcibly cut their hair. The leader of the group was sentenced to 15 years in prison for his crimes earlier this year. The attacks were considered federal hate crimes because a woman's long hair and a man's long beard symbolize signs of submission to God to those who are Amish, according to the Los Angeles Times

'Amish Mafia' Season 3 Spoilers: Reality Show Making 'Special Episode' to 'Prove the Show is Real'? [VIDEO]

In 2006, a 32-year-old truck driver bent on revenge entered a one-room schoolhouse in Lancaster County, killing himself and four young Amish girls in the process.

Amish Mafia is not the only show focused on Amish culture that has made it onto television screens in recent year. TLC premiered Breaking Amish in 2012 and Breaking Amish: LA this year.

Watch a video about how the Amish community feels about Amish Mafia.

The returns for a special episode Tuesday at 9 p.m. on Discovery.


© 2015 Enstarz, All rights reserved. Do not reproduce without permission.

facebook tweet this pin it plus
Contribute to this Story send us a tip send us a tip send us a tip
Sign Up for Newsletters

Around The Web

  • SEARCH ENSTARS

Nick Gordon and Bobbi Kristina Brown

How Is Bobbi Kristina Brown's Boyfriend Nick Gordon Doing In Rehab?

Bobbi Kristina Brown's boyfriend Nick Gordon is said to be doing better now that he is getting help in rehab as she gets treatment as well.

Paul Walker and Cody Walker

Could Paul Walker's Brother Join The Cast Of 'Fast and Furious 8'?

Paul Walker's younger brother, Cody, who helped finish Walker's character arc in 'Furious 7,' has set his eyes on Hollywood.

Heidi Klum

Is Heidi Klum Joining Maddie Ziegler In A New Sia VIdeo?

Is Heidi Klum joining Maddie Ziegler for a new Sia video?

'House of Cards'

Latest Updates About Season 4 Of 'House of Cards'

We're already excited about season 4 of 'House of Cards,' and it seems like things are only going to get murkier in the Underwood household

Hawaii Five 0

'Hawaii Five-0' Finale Plot Revealed, Shocking News For Kono & Danny [VIDEO]

The finale two episodes will be filled with surprises - and surprise guests.

Willie Nelson

Publication Claims Willie Nelson Has Passed At 81 During Death Hoax

When a publication falsely reported that Willie Nelson had died at age 81, the truth came out that it was incorrect.

Maura West

Maura West Confirms If She's Leaving 'General Hospital'

Ava Jerome hasn't been receiving much good news lately on General Hospital, it could be because the actress, Maura West, is planning to leave the soap.

Nick Gordon and Bobbi Kristina Brown

How Is Bobbi Kristina Brown's Boyfriend Nick Gordon Doing In Rehab?

Bobbi Kristina Brown's boyfriend Nick Gordon is said to be doing better now that he is getting help in rehab as she gets treatment as well.

Kim Matula

Is Kim Matula Readying To Return To 'The Bld and the Beautiful' Full Time?

She left her very popular role on The Bold and the Beautiful at the end of last year to pursue other ventures, but new reports allege that Kim Matula wants to return to CBS and her role of Hope Logan once again.

Mimi Faust

Mimi Faust & Nikko Smith's Wife Margeaux Get Physical On 'LHHATL'

Things come to a head between Mimi Faust and Nikko Smith's now infamous wife Margo in a new teaser of 'Love & Hip Hop Atlanta.'

Terminator Genisys

Behind-the-Scene Stills Of Arnold Schwarzenegger’s T-1000 Make-Up In ‘Terminator: Genisys’

Get a look at Arnold Schwarzenegger getting his rugged, bruised and metal interior look for ‘Terminator: Genisys.’

'Fast and Furious 7'

What We Know So Far About 'Fast and Furious 8'

Information about 'Fast and Furious 8' is trickling through.

Tia Mowry

Tia Mowry Possibly Calls Out KeKe Palmer For Getting Close To Her Husband

Former 'The Game' star Tia Mowry might have had a few words for KeKe Palmer after the 'Brotherly Love' actress was a little too friendly with Mowry's husband, Cory Hardict.

Paul Walker and Cody Walker

Could Paul Walker's Brother Join The Cast Of 'Fast and Furious 8'?

Paul Walker's younger brother, Cody, who helped finish Walker's character arc in 'Furious 7,' has set his eyes on Hollywood.

'Fast and Furious 7'

‘Fast and Furious 8’ ‘Has To Be Better’ Than ‘Furious 7'

A new report brings the lowdown on the development of ‘Fast and Furious 8.'

Latest News

Doctor Who

'Doctor Who' Ten Years Later: Why Did Christopher Eccleston Leave? Actor Speaks Out

Christopher Eccleston discusses the circumstances surrounding his short-lived stint as the Doctor

Agents of SHIELD

Post Avengers 2' Plot Revealed For 'Agents of SHIELD', Skye Must Choose A Side

Skye will have a major decision to make after the dust has settled from "Age of Ultron"

Revenge

Who Is Louise Loyal To On 'Revenge'? 'Dramatic Decisions' Unfold Ahead Of Finale

Louise will need to choose a side as season 4 winds down.

Supernatural

'Supernatural' 'Dark Dynasty' Plot Revealed; Can Charlie & Rowena Crack The Book Of The Damned? [VIDEO]

Sam and Dean are headed for a major confrontation with the Stynes as Cas, Charlie and Rowena pour over their latest find.

Hawaii Five 0

'Hawaii Five-0' Finale Plot Revealed, Shocking News For Kono & Danny [VIDEO]

The finale two episodes will be filled with surprises - and surprise guests.

Dave could have a huge secret that changes the case on Secrets and Lies'

Dave Has A Shocking Secret That Could Solve Tom's Murder On 'Secrets & Lies'

His attempt to try and prove his own innocence in the murder of his son has sent Ben Crawford (Ryan Phillippe) on a spree of accusing his neighbors of the murder on Secrets and Lies, but he may quickly learn that someone who is guilty of the crime has actually been hiding right in his own family.

Patrick Dempsey

Derek Saves Lives During 'Grey's Anatomy' Episode 'How to Save a Life'?

Watch the promo for next week's episode of 'Grey's Anatomy'.

Joe & Teresa Giudice

Teresa & Joe Giudice's Home Is Reportedly Going Into Foreclosure

Teresa Giudice may not have a home when she returns to New Jersey from prison early next year.

Featured Videos

From Our Partners

Call Of Champions

'Call Of Champions' MOBA Comes To iOS & Android, Partners With 'League Of Legends' Pros For Alpha Testing [VIDEO]

Three players from the League of Legends pro circuit are collaborating with Spacetime Studio to create and fine tune Call of Champions, the company's upcoming MOBA title for smart devices.

Blackhawks vs. Predators

BLACKHAWKS VS PREDATORS FREE Live Stream: Game 2, Round 1 Stanley Cup Playoffs

The Blackhawks look to take a 2-0 series lead back home while the Predators hope to tie the Round 1 playoff series at 1-1. This game can be live streamed for free here.

Barcelona

Barcelona vs. Valencia Live Stream Free Online: Title Hopes on the Line at the Camp Nou

Barcelona failed to pass its first difficult test of 2015, drawing with Sevilla last Sunday. Now, an even tougher opponent stands between the club and its chase for La Liga glory. The clash between Barcelona and Valencia scheduled for 10 a.m. ET can be live streamed here free. Additional TV coverage can be found on beIN Sports.

Hearthstone: Heroes of Warcraft

Hearthstone Expansion Blackrock Spire Now Open: Learn How To Beat The New Bosses [VIDEO]

The latest wing to Blackrock Mountain in Hearthstone has been opened and excellent YouTuber Trump is here to show you how it's done. Watch and learn.

Islanders vs. Capitals

ISLANDERS vs CAPITALS Live Stream FREE: Round 1, Game 2 Stanley Cup Playoffs

The Islanders look to take a 2-0 series lead while the Washington Capitals hope to even things up at 1-1 in their Stanley Cup playoff game tonight. Watch it for free here.

Inateck Bluetooth 3.0 Ultra Slim Keyboard

Inateck Bluetooth 3.0 Ultra Slim Keyboard Review: A Smarter Option Than Apple's Wireless Keyboard

These days, it helps to have a keyboard that’s versatile. Sure, you can buy a USB keyboard for your computer, but what about when you’re on your tablet, or even your phone? What if you’re on the go and don’t want to lug around a giant keyboard?

Cruz Azul

Morelia vs. Cruz Azul Live Stream Free Online: Liga MX Clausura 2015, Projected Lineups and Tactical Preview

Two clubs chasing the Clausura Liga MX title will do battle today in a league match between Morelia and Cruz Azul. The first-division clash scheduled for 8:30 p.m. ET will be held at the Estadio Morelos in Morelia and can be live streamed here free. Additional TV coverage can be found on ESPN Deportes.

Mortal Kombat X

Mortal Kombat X Characters Rain, Sindel, And Baraka From Story Mode Made Playable By PC Modder

In case you didn't think Mortal Kombat X's pretty impressive roster was deep enough, a PC modder has made normally locked fighters playable.

PS4

PS4 vs Xbox One: March NPD Sales Report Shows Sony Leads Again, Nintendo Posts Strong Hardware Numbers

Sony has continued its sales lead over Xbox One according to the latest NPD numbers, though Nintendo has posted the largest gains for the last month.

Senators vs. Canadiens

SENATORS vs CANADIENS Watch Online FREE: Round 1, Game 2 Stanley Cup Playoffs

The Senators try to even up the playoff series while the Canadiens hope for a 2-0 lead. It can be live streamed for free here.

Real Time Analytics