December 27, 2014 | Updated at 01:21 PM EST The Latest Entertainment & Celebrity News

‘Amish Mafia’ Season 4 News Update: Claims Show Is Fake Resurface Amid Series Finale Talk? [VIDEO]

As fans of Amish Mafia wait to hear if the show will be returning with its full cast for a fourth season, the show is once again facing scrutiny that it is a completely fake series.

By Lauren DuBois, EnStars on Apr 05, 2014 11:39 AM EDT
facebook tweet this pin it plus
Sign Up for Newsletter
  • The cast and crew reach a boiling point on the season 3 finale of 'Amish Mafia'
  • The cast and crew reach a boiling point on the season 3 finale of 'Amish Mafia' (Photo : screen capture)

As fans of Amish Mafia wait to hear if the show will be returning with its full cast for a fourth season, the show is once again facing scrutiny that it is a completely fake series.

Discovery Renews 'Amish Mafia' For Season 4 Despite Cast Threatening Not To Film?

In an article in the Fayetteville Observer, a fan's question about the show's cast and whether or not they were paid actors who were genuinely Amish, led to a revealing answer about ways the show is not true.

The article notes that cast members including Merlin Miller, Lebanon Levi Stoltzfus and Esther Schmucker are not genuinely Amish. While they were raised in Amish homes, they never joined the church, giving them the ability to do things the traditional and religious Amish do not.

'Amish Mafia' Cancelled?

While the cast members themselves have come out on the show before to detail that they were never baptized in Amish churches, the article goes on to point out that Amish experts have called the show's entire premise "ridiculous" in the past.

"It's just sort of an example of the foolishness and stupidity and lies-misrepresentations, I should say-that are promoted (about the Amish) in television," Messiah College professor David Weaver-Zercher was quoted as saying back in a 2012article.

While the cast continues to fight assertions that the show is fake, they appear to also be fighting with the producers and crew of their hit television series as well. In a preview clip for the season 3 finale episode airing April 8, the crew is threatened by the cast and ordered to leave.

Watch the clip below to see the drama between the cast and crew go down.

Amish Mafia airs Tuesdays at 9 p.m. on Discovery.

 


© 2014 Enstarz, All rights reserved. Do not reproduce without permission.

facebook tweet this pin it plus
Contribute to this Story send us a tip send us a tip send us a tip
Sign Up for Newsletters

Around The Web

  • SEARCH ENSTARS

Amber Rose Wiz Khalifa

Amber Rose Talks Moving On From Wiz Khalifa: 'If I Can't Be Married To Him, I Don't Want To Be Married At All'

While model Amber Rose made headlines for twerking on Loyal singer Chris Brown earlier this year, she made it clear whether she is looking to move on after a high profile split with her now ex-husband, rapper Wiz Khalifa.

Ryan Gosling & Rachel McAdams

Is Ryan Gosling Getting Back Together With Rachel McAdams?

Fans have endlessly hoped for a Ryan Gosling and Rachel McAdams reunion since they broke up six years ago, and they could potentially get their wish after all.

Jennifer Aniston

Jennifer Aniston Opens Up About Her Christmas Traditions

Jennifer Aniston loves the holiday season so much that she decorates her home with five Christmas trees.

The cast of 'Red Band Society' a new Fall 2014 Drama Series on FOX

Will 'Red Band Society' Fans Ever Get Closure On The Series? The Answer Is Here!

Things are not looking the best for fans of FOX's Red Band Society who are hoping they can persuade FOX not cancel the freshman series.

Andi Dorfman

Andi Dorfman Shares A Holiday Message For Her Fans

It looks as though Andi Dorfman has a lot to be thankful for these days, and she's definitely showing her appreciation for it.

Brad Pitt

'Sons of Anarchy' Movie Hoax: Brad Pitt Is Not Playing John Teller In Feature Film

A 'Sons of Anarchy' movie hoax had many people fooled with claims that Brad Pitt would be playing a significant character.

'Furious 7'

Vin Diesel Recalls Fan's Touching Remembrance Of Paul Walker

On December 20, Vin Diesel, recalled his encounter with a fan and his touching remembrance of Paul Walker at the red carpet of the trailer release for 'Furious 7.'

'Mad Max: Fury Road'

New 'Mad Max Fury Road' Still Feat. Tom Hardy Unveiled

A new movie still for 'Mad Max: Fury Road' featuring a rugged looking Tom Hardy, who plays the titular role, carrying a limp body was exclusively revealed via Entertainment Weekly.

The cast of 'Red Band Society' a new Fall 2014 Drama Series on FOX

Will The Last Three Episodes Of 'Red Band Society' Get A Chance To Air?

Fans of FOX's Red Band Society may not be able to get their biggest Christmas wish, but there's a chance they will have something to smile about in the New Year.

Kohls

Holiday Store Hours: See Which Big Chains Have Extended Hours

If you’re one of those shoppers who waited till the last minute to buy gifts this holiday season, there’s no need to fret.

Transformers 4: Age of Extinction Poster

'Transformers 4: Age of Extinction' Is The Highest Grossing Of 2014

A new report revealed that 'Transformers 4: Age of Extinction' is the highest grossing movie of 2014.

'Fast and Furious 7'

New Movie Still Feat. Race Wars In 'Furious 7' Revealed

A new movie still featuring the kickoff of the race wars in 'Furious 7' was revealed on December 23.

CVS

See Which Stores Are Open On Christmas Day

While most stores are closed on Christmas Day, there are several that will be open to accommodate food shoppers.

Bow Wow, Erica Mena

'LHHNY' Erica Mena Dishes On Split With Cyn Santana & Facing Criticism About Bow Wow Being 'The One'

Erica Mena has revealed that fans will definitely see the "intense" split between she and Cyn Santana on 'Love & Hip Hop New York' amid her engagement to Bow Wow.

'Terminator: Genisys'

Official Call To Promote 'Terminator: Genisys' Fan Art

Skydance productions, the studio behind 'Terminator: Genisys,' is looking to promote the choicest fan art for the movie.

Latest News

Eminem

Eminem Comes Out As Gay in 'The Interview'

Eminem makes a cameo in Sony’s beleaguered film The Interview where he reveals the unexpected - he’s gay.

Maurice Benard of 'General Hospital'

Sonny Is Here To Stay On 'General Hospital!'

His lock-up in Pentonville jail won't be the last fans of lead mobster Sonny Corinthos (Maurice Benard) will see of him on General Hospital.

Katherine Kelly Lang

Brooke May Be In For Some Major Shocks When She Returns To LA On 'The Bold and the Beautiful'

She's been off at the Milan office for a few months now and been out of the loop about lots of major drama, but Brooke (Katherine Jelly Lang) is set to return to L.A. soon-and could be in for more than a few shocks on The Bold and the Beautiful.

Will and Sonny on 'Days of Our Lives'

Find Out Which Salem Couples Will Likely Break-Up In The New Year On 'Days of Our Lives'

The New Year won't likely be a happy one for several of the current hot couples in Salem on Days of Our Lives.

Survivor

Could 'Survivor's Nadiya Return & Win In 'All Star' Season Just Like Her 'Twinny' Natalie?

After Natalie Anderson won CBS's 'Survivor: San Juan del Sur,' there was some speculation as to whether her twin sister Nadiya Anderson could have possibly won if they were on reverse tribes.

Kathy Bates

Could 'American Horror Story' Stars Jessica Lange Or Kathy Bates Win Golden Globes Despite 'Freak Show' Snub?

FX's 'American Horror Story: Freak Show' wasn't entirely shut out at the upcoming Golden Globes, but could Freak Show's two acting nominees win trophies even if the show itself isn't nominated?

'Dancing With the Stars' pro Val Chmerkovskiy

'Dancing With the Stars' Pro Val Chmerkovskiy Admits Show Packages Aren't Always 'Exact Reality'

'Dancing With the Stars' pro Val Chmerkovskiy recently spoke on a variety of the show's gossip and rumors, including whether or not the show's packages about rehearsal are altogether true.

'The Hobbit: The Battle of the Five Armies'

'Insidious 3' Director Says Hobbit Trilogy 'Disembowel & Pee' On 'The Lord of the Rings' Movies

Leigh Whannell, the director of 'Insidious 3,' recently dissed the Hobbit trilogy stating that they maim the 'Lord and the Rings' series.

'Fast and Furious 7'

Stills Feat. Paul Walker In 'Furious 7' Revealed So Far

As the trailer for 'Furious 7' is finally out showcasing Paul Walker pulling stunning stunts as Brian O'Connor, Enstars rounds up stills and behind-the-scenes pictures of Walker that have been unveiled thus far.

Beauty and the Beast

Fans Vote 'Beauty and the Beast' Best CW Series Of 2014

In a recent poll for best shows of 2014 by a pop culture publication, 'Beauty and the Beast' won the best CW series for the year.

Featured Videos

From Our Partners

youtube.com

'Call of Duty Online' Releases New Promo Trailer Featuring Muscular 'Avengers' Chris Evans, Watch Here (VIDEO)

'Call of Duty Online' Releases New Promo Trailer Featuring Muscular 'Avengers' Chris Evans, Watch Here (VIDEO)

Call of Duty

Call Of Duty Advanced Warfare One Shot Mode Is Snipers-Only With Specialized Classes, Double XP Weekend In Place For Launch

Sledgehammer Games has introduced a new sniper-only game mode into Call of Duty: Advanced Warfare.

Pokemon Uranium

Check Out Pokemon Uranium, A Downloadable Fan Project About Angry Nuclear-Type Pokemon In An Original World

There have been some interesting Pokemon fan projects over the years, but Pokemon Uranium is certainly one of the more unique efforts.

Insurgent movie spoiler, plot – Shailene Woodley’s Tris and James Theo’s Four still on the run from Kate Winslet’s Jeanine

Insurgent movie spoiler, plot – Shailene Woodley’s Tris and James Theo’s Four still on the run from Kate Winslet’s Jeanine

Following Divergent’s $4.9 million debut take at the box office, the Insurgent movie is set for its March 20, 2015, theatrical showing as originally announced by Summit Entertainment, a Lionsgate subsidiary. The two films are of course the adaptations of “Divergent” and “Insurgent,” which are the first and second books in the “Divergent” trilogy for the young-adult genre written by Veronica Roth. The third book in the series, “Allegiant,” will also be made into a movie. In fact, it will be made into two films, namely, The Divergent Series: Allegiant Part I which will be released on March 18, 2016, and The Divergent Series: Allegiant Part II which will screen in theaters on March on March 24, 2017.

Michael Sam

Michael Sam Gay NFL: DE Describes 'Saddest' Childhood to Oprah Winfrey: Said Brothers 'Used To Abuse Me Daily' [VIDEO]

Michael Sam could thank his family for his act of bravery in coming out last year as he began preparation for the NFL Draft. But it's the opposite of a heart-warming story.

Colin Kaepernick

San Francisco 49ers Rumors: Ex-Niners QB Jeff Garcia Says Kaepernick Offers To Help Solve Colin Kaepernick's Struggles [VIDEO]

Good or bad, Colin Kaepernick's play this season never had been compared to that of former San Francisco 49ers quarterback Jeff Garcia. Until Garcia made the comparison himself.

Taken 3 movie spoiler, plot - The Final Chapter in Liam Neeson’s ‘Brian Mills’ Saga

Taken 3 movie spoiler, plot - The Final Chapter in Liam Neeson’s ‘Brian Mills’ Saga

Taken 3, officially sub-titled It Ends Here, will show in theaters on January 9, 2015. It is the third and final installment in the ‘Taken’ film series written by Luc Besson and Robert Mark Kamen. As with the original and the sequel, Taken 3 stars Liam Neeson in the lead as ex-CIA operative Brian Mills.

Rusev

WWE SmackDown Live Stream Online: Watch Rusev Defends United States Championship and More, Final SD of 2014

Tonight at 8 p.m. ET, the WWE presents SmackDown from Sioux City, Iowa in what is the final episode for 2014 as the company counts down to the Royal Rumble live from the Wells Fargo Center on Jan. 25 in Philadelphia. The event can be live streamed here.

CoolStuffInc

Year End Card And Board Game Sales From Cool Stuff Inc: Magic Singles, Cardfight Vanguard, The Witcher And More

Need a place to spend some of that sweet Christmas money? Head on over to Cool Stuff Inc and pick up some board and/or card games to keep you warm this winter.

Real Time Analytics