October 21, 2014 | Updated at 12:36 PM EDT The Latest Entertainment & Celebrity News

‘Amish Mafia’ Season 4 News Update: Claims Show Is Fake Resurface Amid Series Finale Talk? [VIDEO]

As fans of Amish Mafia wait to hear if the show will be returning with its full cast for a fourth season, the show is once again facing scrutiny that it is a completely fake series.

By Lauren DuBois, EnStars on Apr 05, 2014 11:39 AM EDT
facebook tweet this pin it plus
Sign Up for Newsletter
  • The cast and crew reach a boiling point on the season 3 finale of 'Amish Mafia'
  • The cast and crew reach a boiling point on the season 3 finale of 'Amish Mafia' (Photo : screen capture)

As fans of Amish Mafia wait to hear if the show will be returning with its full cast for a fourth season, the show is once again facing scrutiny that it is a completely fake series.

Discovery Renews 'Amish Mafia' For Season 4 Despite Cast Threatening Not To Film?

In an article in the Fayetteville Observer, a fan's question about the show's cast and whether or not they were paid actors who were genuinely Amish, led to a revealing answer about ways the show is not true.

The article notes that cast members including Merlin Miller, Lebanon Levi Stoltzfus and Esther Schmucker are not genuinely Amish. While they were raised in Amish homes, they never joined the church, giving them the ability to do things the traditional and religious Amish do not.

'Amish Mafia' Cancelled?

While the cast members themselves have come out on the show before to detail that they were never baptized in Amish churches, the article goes on to point out that Amish experts have called the show's entire premise "ridiculous" in the past.

"It's just sort of an example of the foolishness and stupidity and lies-misrepresentations, I should say-that are promoted (about the Amish) in television," Messiah College professor David Weaver-Zercher was quoted as saying back in a 2012article.

While the cast continues to fight assertions that the show is fake, they appear to also be fighting with the producers and crew of their hit television series as well. In a preview clip for the season 3 finale episode airing April 8, the crew is threatened by the cast and ordered to leave.

Watch the clip below to see the drama between the cast and crew go down.

Amish Mafia airs Tuesdays at 9 p.m. on Discovery.

 


© 2014 Enstarz, All rights reserved. Do not reproduce without permission.

facebook tweet this pin it plus
Contribute to this Story send us a tip send us a tip send us a tip
Sign Up for Newsletters

Around The Web

  • SEARCH ENSTARS

Omarion & Apryl Jones

'LHHH' Star Omarion Speaks On 'Untrue' Rumors He & Apryl Jones Split

VH1's Love & Hip Hop Hollywood star Omarion has spoken out about rumors that he and Apryl Jones have called it quits after speculation that her ex-boyfriend fathered the couple's baby boy.

Mattie Breaux of 'Party Down South'

'Party Down South' Star Mattie Breaux Injured In A Four-Wheeling Accident--Find Out How She's Doing!

Her drunken alter ego has gotten her into some trouble before on Party Down South, but this time Mattie Breaux is being forced to deal with something that can't be blamed on Martha.

Stevie J & Joseline Hernandez

Mimi Faust Blasts 'LHHATL' Co-Stars Stevie J & Joseline Hernandez: 'They're Going To Kill Each Other'

As fans continue to wonder whether Love & Hip Hop Atlanta breakout stars Stevie J and Joseline Hernandez are really expecting a child together, VH1 has revealed what his ex-girlfriend Mimi Faust and their other co-stars really think about their relationship.

Scott Porter

The CW Speaks On Rumors That 'Hart Of Dixie' Has Been Cancelled, Scott Porter Says 'Sun Sets On Bluebell'

The CW has broken its silence after rumors swirled that one of its popular series Hart of Dixie was coming to an end after its highly anticipated fourth season.

John Carroll Lynch

'American Horror Story': Twisty The Clown VERY Bitter About Freak Show Being In Town

John Carroll Lynch plays Twisty the Clown, one of the most terrifying characters on television on 'American Horror Story: Freak Show,' and the actor recently discussed some of the character's motivations.

Longmire

Lou Diamond Phillips Hints At 'Longmire' Salvation

Fans were outraged when A&E elected to cancel the crime drama 'Longmire' after three seasons as they network's highest-rated scripted series.

Taylor 'Lil Bit' Wright of 'Party Down South'

'Party Down South' Fans Petitioning To Get Lil' Bit Back On TV?

She chose to leave Party Down South after citing safety concerns, but it doesn't mean that Taylor 'Lil'Bit' Wright's fans are ready to let go of seeing her on their television screens.

Longmire

'Longmire' Star Reveals When Their Contracts Expire

The cast and crew of 'Longmire', which was canceled by A&E after three seasons, have urged fans to be patient as the series looks for a new network.

Orange is the New Black

What We Know So Far About 'Orange Is the New Black' Season 3

While relatively few plot details are known so far about the highly anticipated third season of Netflix's 'Orange Is the New Black,' there has been a fair amount of information that has been revealed over the past few months.

Mattie Breaux of 'Party Down South'

'Party Down South' Star Mattie Breaux Injured In A Four-Wheeling Accident--Find Out How She's Doing!

Her drunken alter ego has gotten her into some trouble before on Party Down South, but this time Mattie Breaux is being forced to deal with something that can't be blamed on Martha.

Longmire

'Longmire' Writer Reccomends New Strategy For Series

Fans of 'Longmire' began to organize "Twitter Stampedes" to promote the series following A&E's decision to cancel the crime drama and continue to do so as producers search to find the program a new network.

Hazel-E

Hazel E Slams 'Side Chick, Groupie' Masika Amid Rumors She's Dating Yung Berg

Hazel E has brutally dissed her Love & Hip Hop Hollywood co-star Masika amid speculation that Masika is dating her ex, Yung Berg.

Longmire

'Longmire' Cancellation Takes A Toll On Cast

As A&E's axed 'Longmire' continues the long search for a new network, cast and crew have stopped to remind fans that the series' message of camaraderie is just as much alive off-screen as it is on.

Taylor 'Lil Bit' Wright of 'Party Down South'

'Party Down South' Star Taylor 'Lil Bit' Wright Is PREGNANT!

Fans initially questioned her plans to leave Party Down South after the show's second season, but it appears everything has worked out for the best for Taylor 'Lil Bit' Wright-who has officially announced that she is pregnant and expecting a baby with her new boyfriend.

Bones

'Bones' 200th Episode Pays Tribute To Hollywood Legend For 200th Episode

The highly anticipated 200th episode of Fox's 'Bones' is up ahead and the theme of the episode has been revealed: Alfred Hitchcock.

Latest News

The Dovekeepers

Cote de Pablo Gets Intimate On Set With 'Dovekeepers' Co-Star

Roma Downey shared a new photo from the set of The Dovekeepers which featured the show’s leading men.

Archer

What Two Characters Are Put In Charge Of The New 'Archer' Headquaters?

It seems like a lot of pieces are going to have to be picked up in the next season of 'Archer' after the spy game was dropped. But with it coming back, what does the group have in store and who could be the new dynamic duo?

Wendy Williams

Wendy Williams Says R. Kelly Storyline Will Be Shown In Aaliyah 'Princess Of R&B' Movie

Now that Wendy Williams has been dubbed Executive Producer of the controversial biopic of the life and story of Aaliyah, she revealed that she Lifetime will show Aaliyah's alleged relationship with R&B singer R. Kelly.

Drea de Matteo

What Drea de Matteo Chose To Take From Set of 'Sons of Anarchy'

FX's 'Sons of Anarchy' is winding down to a close and one of its stars has decided to take something from the set to remember her experience.

Todd & Chase Chrisley

Writer Disses 'Chrisley Knows Best' Star Todd, 'He Is Clearly Exploiting His Minor Children For Ratings'

As many fans await the highly anticipated return of USA's Chrisley Knows Best, a Salt Late City, Utah reporter has called out the family, specifically patriarch Todd Chrisley, for being fake.

'Party Down South' Cast Members: Lyle Boudreaux, Josh Murray, Ryan Daddy Richards, Mattie Breaux, Tiffany Heinen, Lauren White & Walt Windham

How Is The Cast Of 'Party Down South' Celebrating The Holiday Season? Details About Their Special Episodes Revealed!

Fans have loved watching the cast of Party Down South get into trouble during their drunkest moments thus far in both South Carolina and Georgia-and now, they'll get to see how the cast plans on celebrating the holidays as well.

Teresa Giudice

Teresa Giudice To Live In Halfway House After Prison Release, 'Expected To Get A Job'

While Teresa Giudice's upcoming stint in prison is the topic of several conversations, new reports reveal what other punishment Giudice will have to undergo once she is released from jail.

Jackie Christie

Jackie Christie Reveals If 'BBWLA' Will Return For Season 4

While countless eyes are on the extremely successful Love & Hip Hop franchises, Basketball Wives LA star Jackie Christie has revealed whether fans will see that series back on VH1.

Lisa Rinna

Lisa Rinna Sells Out Fashion On QVC & Thanks Her Fans From 'Bottom' Of Her Heart

Not only is 'Real Housewives of Beverly Hills' cast member Lisa Rinna going to be a reality star, but the actress is a bonafide fashion mogul.

Madeline calls in some favors to help Nina on the October 21, 2014 episode of 'General Hospital'

Madeline Helps Nina With Her Revenge Plans On 'General Hospital'

Nina (Michelle Stafford) has become increasingly more upset and unraveled over time, and in an attempt to keep herself from being a target of her daughter's revenge plots, Madeline (Donna Mills) will go to new extremes on General Hospital.

Featured Videos

From Our Partners

Nina Dobrev

Celebrity Leaked Photos 2014: 'Vampire Diaries' Star Nina Dobrev Calls Scandal 'An Invasion Of Privacy' [VIDEO]

Nina Dobrev is the latest female celebrity affected by the nude photo scandal.

Sid Meier's Civilization: Beyond Earth

Civilization: Beyond Earth Mac And Linux Release Date Set For Holiday 2014, Steam Workshop Mod Support Planned

Prolific Mac porter Aspyr announced today that the Mac and Linux ports for the upcoming Sid Meier's Civilization: Beyond Earth will be available this holiday season.

The Undertaker

Hell in a Cell 2014 Matches: Top 5 Hell in a Cell Bouts Of All Time [VIDEOS] [PHOTOS]

A look back at the Top 5 WWE Hell in a Cell matches since the bouts inception in 1997.

Joan Rivers

Joan Rivers Death Lawsuit: Without Biopsy, Medical Examiner Can't Determine If Death Was 'Preventable' [VIDEO]

There was never an autopsy performed on Joan Rivers, which means her true cause of death may never be revealed.

The Legend of Korra

Legend Of Korra Game Release Date Arrives Alongside Launch Trailer: Available Today On PlayStation, Xbox Versions Hit Tomorrow [VIDEO]

PlatinumGames and Nickelodeon have finally released their anticipated brawler title based on the hit series, The Legend of Korra. And there's a new 3DS title coming next week, too.

Manny Pacquiao

Manny Pacquiao Next Fight: Chris Algieri Calls Pacman Playing Basketball 'Silly' [VIDEO]

Manny Pacquiao's upcoming title fight with WBO junior welterweight champion Chris Algieri is almost exactly one month away, but that hasn't stopped Pacquiao from pursuing other interests outside the ring.

Oscar Pistorius

Paralympic Sprinter Oscar Pistorius Begins Five-Year Prison Sentence For Killing Of Girlfriend [VIDEO]

Olympic and Paralympic sprinter Oscar Pistorius started his five-year jail sentence on Tuesday for killing his girlfriend Reeva Steenkamp, marking the end of a trial that has gripped South Africa and millions around the world.

Santa Claus

Stuck In Chimney: California Woman Arrested After Getting Stuck In The Chimney Of Her Online Lover's House [VIDEO]

Ho Ho Ho! It is not Christmas yet, but that didn't stop a California woman from climbing into a chimney.

WWE 2K15

WWE 2K15 Video: John Cena Rages Against The Dying Of The Light In Latest Commercial

Wrestling may be fake, but the words of Dylan Thomas are eternally real. John Cena takes a moment to recite one of the Welsh poet's most famous works in the latest trailer for WWE 2K15.

Real Time Analytics