July 30, 2015 | Updated at 06:42 PM EDT The Latest Entertainment & Celebrity News

‘Amish Mafia’ Season 4 News Update: Claims Show Is Fake Resurface Amid Series Finale Talk? [VIDEO]

As fans of Amish Mafia wait to hear if the show will be returning with its full cast for a fourth season, the show is once again facing scrutiny that it is a completely fake series.

By Lauren DuBois, EnStars on Apr 05, 2014 11:39 AM EDT
facebook tweet this pin it plus
Sign Up for Newsletter
  • The cast and crew reach a boiling point on the season 3 finale of 'Amish Mafia'
  • The cast and crew reach a boiling point on the season 3 finale of 'Amish Mafia' (Photo : screen capture)

As fans of Amish Mafia wait to hear if the show will be returning with its full cast for a fourth season, the show is once again facing scrutiny that it is a completely fake series.

Discovery Renews 'Amish Mafia' For Season 4 Despite Cast Threatening Not To Film?

In an article in the Fayetteville Observer, a fan's question about the show's cast and whether or not they were paid actors who were genuinely Amish, led to a revealing answer about ways the show is not true.

The article notes that cast members including Merlin Miller, Lebanon Levi Stoltzfus and Esther Schmucker are not genuinely Amish. While they were raised in Amish homes, they never joined the church, giving them the ability to do things the traditional and religious Amish do not.

'Amish Mafia' Cancelled?

While the cast members themselves have come out on the show before to detail that they were never baptized in Amish churches, the article goes on to point out that Amish experts have called the show's entire premise "ridiculous" in the past.

"It's just sort of an example of the foolishness and stupidity and lies-misrepresentations, I should say-that are promoted (about the Amish) in television," Messiah College professor David Weaver-Zercher was quoted as saying back in a 2012article.

While the cast continues to fight assertions that the show is fake, they appear to also be fighting with the producers and crew of their hit television series as well. In a preview clip for the season 3 finale episode airing April 8, the crew is threatened by the cast and ordered to leave.

Watch the clip below to see the drama between the cast and crew go down.

Amish Mafia airs Tuesdays at 9 p.m. on Discovery.

 


© 2015 Enstarz, All rights reserved. Do not reproduce without permission.

facebook tweet this pin it plus
Contribute to this Story send us a tip send us a tip send us a tip
Sign Up for Newsletters

Around The Web

  • SEARCH ENSTARS

Big Brother 17

'Big Brother 17's Jason Finally Starts Campaigning To Stay, But Is It Too Late?

Will Jason be able to squeak out of being evicted this week?

The Duggar Family

Is The Duggar Family Going Broke?

Is The Duggar family at risk of losing it all?

Bobbi Kristina Brown

Bobbi Kristina Brown's Friend Calls Out Her Family For 'Planning For Her Death'

A friend of Bobbi Kristina Brown has turned the tables on her family and suggested revealed what she said is the truth behind what happened leading up to Bobbi Kristina's death.

Draya Michele

Shaunie O'Neal, Evelyn Lozada & Tami Roman Might Be Anti Draya Michele On New 'BBWLA'

The ladies of 'Basketball Wives LA' have their differences this season but one thing they can agree on is they're not fans of Draya Michele's new attitude.

Mark Harmon

'NCIS' Season 13 Premiere Episode Officially Titled 'Stop the Bleeding'

What does the premiere episode title of 13th season of 'NCIS' mean?

Ashlyn Pearce

Ashlyn Pearce Speaks Out About Aly's Shocking Death On 'The Bold and the Beautiful'

The actress took to social media to address the trn of events and thank fans for their support.

WWE Raw

Monday Night 'Raw' LIVE STREAM Free: Watch WWE Wrestling 2015 Online @ 8 pm ET

Catch Brock Lessner and the Undertaker live online

Future and Ciara

Future Just Can't Stop Talking About His Ex In Interviews

Future admits to feeling 'embarrassed' for his ex-fiance Ciara.

The cast of 'Days of Our Lives' posing at the 42nd Annual Daytime Emmy Awards

Is 'Days of Our Lives' No Longer In Jeopardy Of Being Canceled?

The show has seen a spike in viewership.

Draya Michele & Orlando Scandrick

Draya Michele Rocks Engagement Ring After Split With Orlando Scandrick

Draya Michele proudly wore what looks like her engagement ring after she and Dallas Cowboys star Orlando Scandrick battled it out on social media following their split.

Adiz 'Bambi' Benson

Bambi Gets Way Too Close To Another Man On 'LHHATL' Amid Lil Scrappy Drama

Bambi might have found comfort with an aspiring rapper as she and Lil Scrappy face challenges in their relationship on 'Love & Hip Hop Atlanta.'

Witches Of East End

'Witches Of East End' Petition Is Still Gaining Signatures

It's been months since the cancellation of 'Witches of East End' was announced, but the petition to help bring it back is (surprisingly) still open.

Cecil the Lion

The Internet Is Pissed At An American Dentist Who Killed Cecil The Lion

After Walter Palmer was outed by the media, people took to social media to express outrage at him.

Latest News

Shirtless Guy Listening To Music Outside

Which Tune Should Be Crowned The Song Of Summer 2015?

There's only one month left to go in 2015's summer and we want to know what tune you think is the song of the summer.

Ray Tensing

The Video Of Samuel DuBose's Murder By A Cop Goes Viral

Former Police Officer Ray Tensing was indicted on a murder charge after his body camera video was released, revealing the true event

kale

A New Report Says That Kale May Not Be That Healthy For You

It seems like the leafy vegetable that EVERYONE is obsessed with may do your body more harm than good.

Jen Welter & Becky Hammon

Meet The Women Who Are Changing The Face Of The Professional Male Sports

Jen Welter & Becky Hammon are proof that women are not just cheerleaders for the NFL or NBA anymore.

Kylie Jenner

Is Kylie Jenner Celebrating Her Upcoming Birthday In Canada?

Kylie Jenner might be getting paid $200k at her own birthday party.

Sandra Bland

Are Police-Involved Deaths Of Black Women Being Ignored By The Media?

Sandra Bland is not the first African-American women to die in police custody—so why isn’t the media talking about the others?

The Clooneys

The Clooneys Attend Guy Ritchie's Wedding

Guy Ritchie's countryside wedding was an A-list affair.

Jenelle Evans

Jenelle Evans Prepares For Custody Battle With Mother Barbara

Jenelle Evans and her mother are due in court next week.

Real Time Analytics